Saturday, June 09, 2007

IIMs: Struggling against the dictatorship of Arjun Singh

Remember the days when former Human Resource and Development (HRD) Minister Murali Manohar Joshi during the National Democratic Alliance regime had slashed the heavy fees of Indian Institution of Management (IIMs)? Newspapers, TV channels and all forms of media termed the decision as a move to promote fanaticism, fascism or saffronisation of management education.

Now consider today's position... The seven prestigious IIMs do not know, whether to admit students or not. Thanx to the present HRD Minister Arjun Singh, IIMs have no option left but to keep waiting for government directives and court directive for conducting the admission process.

Singh's decision to provide 50 per cent seats to candidates from reserved categories in IIMs instead of the present 14 per cent quota (for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes) has been challenged in the Supreme Court (SC). Whether this quota is justified or not, is an altogether different issue.

But when the SC has three times scrapped government's request to approve this additional reservation quota from present academic year, why is the HRD Ministry not allowing IIMs to start the admission process?

Despite of having clear SC directives, the IIM admission rpocess is held up only due to the stubborn attitude of Arjun Singh. What do we call this attitude, which makes the union minister to downplay the directives of the apex court?

Is this not dictatorship? If yes, then why are we not ready to 'term' it that way?

Sunday, December 25, 2005

dubai - a modern Islamic city

Recently, I had a chance to visit Dubai, one of the important shopping destinations on this globe. I landed there with a prejudiced mind of going to an Islamic country, where there is no democracy. There would be some restrictions for tourists and a number of other rules to be followed while in public places.

However, the scene was contrary. Dubai is a beautiful city with advanced infrastructure already in place. The roads are good and people travel only in four wheelers.

People are free to wear whatever type of clothes they want to. I could find women (Indian as well as from other countries) wearing western outfits, which even Mumbai or Delhi girls would try to avoid. Outsiders constitute most of Dubai’s population and hence finding Muslim women as well as the traditionally dressed Arab men is a tough job. There is no law, which prohibits Muslim women from dressing up in western outfits. If a family allows a woman to wear clothes of her choice, then the administration has no problems.

Interestingly, pork is also available in market. It's only liquor that is not sold at public spaces, which in a way is a good sign. People are free to follow their religion but one is not supposed to celebrate a religious event to block traffic and create nuisance. And this rule is there for the Muslim community as well.

Now I think of our country, which we say is the largest democracy in this world. We tell our international tennis star Sania Mirza to wear a burkha; we fight for having a ban on cow slaughter; we set on fire vehicles and pelt stones at shops and police during Ganesh immersion procession when we are asked to observe discipline; we fail to observe civic sense; we fail to observe traffic rules.

Somehow, I feel, the so called fundamentalist country like United Arab Emirates, where Dubai and other cities like Sharjah and Abu Dhabi are there, is far better than ours. May be, we Indians enjoy much more freedom than what we really need or what we deserve. I might be wrong if the perspective is broadened, but yes, a short stay in Dubai made me think this way, at least for a while.

Saturday, August 27, 2005

the media buzz in mumbai...

i have been to mumbai for the first time after the three newspapers viz mumbai mirror, the hidustan times and DNA were launched. before i reached here, i had heard a lot about these newspapers, their style and performance. and, i was quite eager to go through these products. in addition, two news channels India TV (the one which did the shakti kapoor sting operation) and dainik jagran's Channel 7 JTV have also come up.

the first day, i bought all the english newspapers (times of india, HT, mirror, mid-day, indian express, asian age, DNA and free press journal) and it took me around five hours to go through some 350 pages of these newspapers.

clearly, it's just competition that has made these print medium products to provide this much of matter at a minimal cost.

i found the times of india acting in a typical "market leader" fashion while the HT being concentrating at its target readership. the HT did not even bother to provide stuff from mumbai suburbs while the DNA had full two pages of the same element.

interestingly, the DNA has changed the "byline" criteria of news stories. all news stories filed by DNA reporters are "byline" stories. it does not mean, they are exclusive. it simply means that the reporter who files these copies gets the credit for the same.

for a person like me, who is somewhat orthodox when it comes to journalistic ethics, this media buzz is something odd. and i am happy to know that there is severe shorage of journalists in mumbai. may be, i can find a good job here, i thought. i did not believe that there is this shortage but then i had to believe the same due to an incident.

a reporter (?) working with Channel 7 JTV claimed that the channel was launched by NDTV (which is not the case as mentioned in the first para of this write up). i was shocked to know that a reporter who is a mumbai citizen, has seen this media buzz developing and has grown in this culture is unaware of the parent organisation of her own media establishment.

Saturday, August 13, 2005

Is Congress a secular party?

the justice nanavati commissions' report and the action taken report (ATR) by the central government have proved that Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and Shiv Sena (SS) are not the only parties with anti-secularism attitude.

the nanavati commission has mentioned the involvement of top congress leadership in the well-planned carnage of sikh community after indira ganhi's assasination. the central government (lead by congress) however gave stupid excuses in the ATR to deny an action against senior leaders like union minister jagtish tytler and member of parliament sajjan kumar. as expected, the opposition made an issue out of it and pressurised the government to take an appropriate action against those indicated by the commission report.

the government finally made tytler to resign as minister followed by sajjan kumar resigning as chairman of a government board. the severe criticism came from BJP and shiromani akali dal along with the left parties and few others from the united progressive alliance partners. the BJP lead the agitations but probably forgot what had happened in gujrat. the party however assured that they will obey the inquiry commission's report in case of gujrat riots.

the question now is that why media have tagged only BJP and SS as anti-secularist parties? the congress right from its formation has been involved in acts that are not secular. do congressmen have an answer to why a large number of brahmins were killed when nathuram godse assasinated mahatma gandhi? why more than 4000 sikhs were brutally murdered by congress party workers after indira gandhi was killed by her sikh bodyguard? why did rajiv gandhi revert the Supreme Court's order to appease muslim fundamentalists in shah bano case? aren't these incidents sufficient enough to say that congress is not at secular?

when it comes to BJP and SS, may be they are wrong as they do not believe in secularism. but then at least they are sincere to the ideology they believe in. what about congress? this national party which has enjoyed power for more than 48 years in free india wears a mask of secularism but is the real culprit that sprung religious fanaticism and anti-secular movement in india. and look, the media are afraid to raise these issues.......

Sunday, July 10, 2005

Cricket: Can we differentiate between Karachi and London?

When it comes to cricket, the white countires have always shown their snobbish attitude and have been looking down at the black countries. The British team is all scheduled to visit Pakistan and as usual, questions are being raised about the feasibility of the match to be played in Karachi. The Pakistani city has seen increasing violence in recent times and the visitors, especially the white countries lead by Australia have always denied to play here.

The Britishers are raising all types of issues questionning the security arrangements in Karachi. But unfortunately, they are sure about holding a one-dayer as well as a test match in the Ashes series at Lords, London. Did they ask the Aaustralians, if the place was secured enough in the wake of the serial blasts that hit London.

Just put India, Pakistan or any other black country in place of England. I am sure, the Australians would have reached home by this time.

The Britishers, Australians and Kiwis have always dealt in this fashion with teams from Indian sub-sontinent. In an effort to maintain their hegemony, these countries have forgotten that cricket is considered to be a game of gentlemen.

Shame Shame Shame !!! These are the only words that need to be used to condemn the attitude of these countries.

Saturday, July 09, 2005

Ayodhya and London attacks: Islamic fanaticism needs to be discussed

The recent attack on Ram Janmabhoomi site followed by the serial blasts in London are the unfortunate examples of Islamic religious fanatism. The media however are yet to discuss this link and there is every possibility that the international as well as Indian media (so called balanced and secularist) are deliberately trying to avoid this angle.

The theory of Islamic fanatism teaches the followers that the kafirs are the true enemies (kafir is the one who does not believe in Islam) of Islam and should be finished at every cost. The Islamic fanatics think that Hinduism and Christianism are the biggest threats to Islam and hence should be ended from the earth.

The international media being controlled by the developed nations and lead by United States of America, will take up this link after the current happenings cools down. But I am afraid, if any of the Indian media will openly dare to establish think link. In India, media are all set to discuss the Hindu fanaticism. But when it comes to Islamic or Christian fanaticism, the media fold their weapons.

As in case of Gujrat riots..... The riots were unfortunate, no doubt and Modi government has faced a lot of criticism over the happenings. But what about the Sabarmati Express incident that ignited these riots? Did any of the Indian media discussed the Islamic fanaticism that burnt 58 Sadhus to death inside a train coach?

The Indian media failed to raise this issue and what finally appeared in International scenario was, the Hindu fanaticism in India is at its peak. India media hence need to go hard at such issues. Let the world know, Why Hindu fanaticism is growing (may be) in India? The world should understand that Hindu fanaticism has its roots in the emergence of Islamic fanaticism in Indian sub continent.

Thursday, June 30, 2005

nominations for Nobel Peace Prize

Yesterday, I was going through the list of 91 Indian women who have been recommended for this year's Nobel Peace Prize. The list includes Medha Patkar, Kiran Bedi, Mallika Sarabhai, Aruna Roy, Mahashweta Devi and few other women. I do not know the various criteria considered while awarding the Noble Peace Prize. But what I feel is, none of the women recommended deserve the peace prize.

I know, thounsands of people would criticise me for my statement. But yes, Mallika Sarabhai who is a Katthak dancer or Kiran Bedi, who is an IPS officer surely do not deserve the peace prize. The only strong contendor could be NBA activist Medha Patkar. However, the extremist attitude of Patkar, her unnecessary opposition to the process of urbanisation and in a way to globalisation will definitely keep her far away from the prize. And again, is there an element of 'peace process' when it comes to Patkar's achievments?

Actively involved in NBA, Patkar has been criticising the government bodies for almost all the reasons. But unfortunately, she has not been able to give appropriate solutions to the problmes as well. No doubt, she is completely devoted for the cause; she is not running after publicity and surely, she has not capital interests from NBA. But, does she deserve a peace prize for her activities?

It is being said that the 'lobby' factor has to work if one has to win a Nobel prize. I do not want to say that all the prize winners are far better than Patkar. Hence, after doing so much of work, the Indian woman activist will have to build a good 'lobby' of supporters to make it to the prize. Generally, Indian fail here. Let's see, what happens to Patkar !!!