Thursday, June 30, 2005

nominations for Nobel Peace Prize

Yesterday, I was going through the list of 91 Indian women who have been recommended for this year's Nobel Peace Prize. The list includes Medha Patkar, Kiran Bedi, Mallika Sarabhai, Aruna Roy, Mahashweta Devi and few other women. I do not know the various criteria considered while awarding the Noble Peace Prize. But what I feel is, none of the women recommended deserve the peace prize.

I know, thounsands of people would criticise me for my statement. But yes, Mallika Sarabhai who is a Katthak dancer or Kiran Bedi, who is an IPS officer surely do not deserve the peace prize. The only strong contendor could be NBA activist Medha Patkar. However, the extremist attitude of Patkar, her unnecessary opposition to the process of urbanisation and in a way to globalisation will definitely keep her far away from the prize. And again, is there an element of 'peace process' when it comes to Patkar's achievments?

Actively involved in NBA, Patkar has been criticising the government bodies for almost all the reasons. But unfortunately, she has not been able to give appropriate solutions to the problmes as well. No doubt, she is completely devoted for the cause; she is not running after publicity and surely, she has not capital interests from NBA. But, does she deserve a peace prize for her activities?

It is being said that the 'lobby' factor has to work if one has to win a Nobel prize. I do not want to say that all the prize winners are far better than Patkar. Hence, after doing so much of work, the Indian woman activist will have to build a good 'lobby' of supporters to make it to the prize. Generally, Indian fail here. Let's see, what happens to Patkar !!!

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home